Jul 03 2008
Sharia, the Cardinal and divorce
Apparently the Lord Chief Justice has now come out in support of Rowan Williams’ earlier controversial (and in my view poorly presented, and wilfully misunderstood) remarks about Sharia and UK law. The bit of the Telegraph’s report that got my attention, however, was this:
Cardinal Cormac Murphy O’Connor, the Archbishop of Westminster and leader of Britain’s Catholics, said that people should live under the laws of the UK.
His spokesman said: “As the Cardinal has consistently said and indeed said earlier this year, was that Britons should abide by and be subject to the law of the land.”
And where, precisely does this leave the whole apparatus of Canon Law and marriage tribunals, which refuse to recognise as valid at least any second wedding (if not any first secular wedding) contracted by the state, and likewise refuse to recognise the state’s divorce law as ending a marriage, unless a couple have also followed the Church’s annulment procedures? This is, it seems to me, exactly an example of a religious community adjudicating certain practices by a a separate and different code of law to that which is enshrined in the law of the land.

