MetaCatholic

MetaCatholic

a few graffiti on the wall of life

MetaCatholic RSS Feed
 
 
 
 

Archive for Faith and History

Competing narratives of the Church’s Fall

In a very stimulating post today Halden offers a reflection on two different narratives of Christian decline. One, associated with Hauerwas and others, attributes it to the Constantinian capitulation of the Church. The other (which I think is more diffuse – O’Donovan and Milbank are rather different) is with the modern turn to the individual, [...]

The Shroud and the Science

Antonio Lombatti asked me if I had the time to take a look at tonight’s BBC documentary on The Turin Shroud. (This iPlayer link will work for the next six days for those who can get the service.) He was particularly interested in what Professor Christopher Ramsey of the C14 testing laboratory in Oxford had [...]

Why Jim West is wrong

Jim has a characteristically diffident post on what he learned from Karl Barth.
It is the undeniable, irrefutable, unalterable, eternal truth that the Gospel is in and of itself thoroughly sufficient and that the Gospel + Anything = heresy.

Leaving aside the consummate irony of a disciple of Bultmann (perhaps the greatest 20th century example [...]

The virgin birth — Luke’s new creation story

Peter Kirk posts what I regard to be a mistaken reading of the birth narratives, especially the Lukan account. Before I interact with what he says about his own views, however, I want to try to clear up some confusions about my views as he portrays them in the post.
First, I believe there is almost [...]

Yet again, historiography and the virginal conception

In a comment on this earlier post, Peter Kirk said:
I am worried by your lack of interest in what actually happened, as a historical event. Sure, that is not all there is to the Christmas story. There is a place for “the challenging diversity that nurtures our encounter with Jesus”. But that encounter is nothing [...]

Once more, Matthew, Luke or a Christmas harmony?

Michael Halcomb has responded in some detail to my post yesterday (which was in turn a comment on this post of his), arguing for the compatibility of the Matthean and Lukan birth narratives. (He is not alone, as this comment by Peter Kirk reveals.) I would again like to repay the compliment. I have a [...]

Welcome

I'm Doug Chaplin, parish priest and human being. Sometimes I have thoughts I want to share. Sometimes I have thoughts I should keep to myself. Sometimes I get them confused. Happy browsing.

Categories

Previous Posts

Admin

Posts this Month

October 2008
S M T W T F S
« Sep    
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Blogroll

My Sites

Legal Notice

I reserve the right to publish legal notices, emails or letters concerning the operation or content of this website at my sole discretion unless there has been an explicit agreement in advance in writing to keep such communications confidential. If you wish to guarantee that such communications remain unpublished, you must contact the site in advance to request my agreement. You can do this by emailing doug at metacatholic dot co dot uk. Any further correspondence related to an initial communication will be treated on the same terms as described in the previous paragraph, unless an explicit agreement to the contrary has been reached and confirmed in writing.

Spam Blocked